Banita Parry, a famous postcolonial theorist, argues for a materialist critique of postcolonial theory. Postcolonial theory has largely focused on the representation of colonized people by the colonizers. Parry challenges this emphasis and argues that unless the atrocities and oppression of the colonizers are critically examined, and the resistance of colonized people to decolonize themselves is acknowledged and discussed, there can be no real independence. The colonizers introduced numerous policies and programs that were primarily designed to maintain their control over the people. Although these measures sometimes appeared to provide administrative or social benefits, their ultimate purpose was to consolidate colonial authority and keep the people under control.
We inherited this system of authority, control and manipulation along with the privileged position of the English language. English is not the lingua franca of the Pakistani people, yet it enjoys the status of a powerful language. African writers such as Chinua Achebe and Ngũgĩ, among many others, proposed different approaches to decolonization through resisting the colonial discourse. In line with Frantz Fanon's ideas, they emphasized the need to resist and challenge the dominance of colonial cultural and intellectual heritage. Ngũgĩ advocated writing in African languages as a means of resisting linguistic and cultural domination. We, however, have not been able to pursue a comparable transformation on a large scale because the education system through which our people are educated was largely designed under colonial rule and has continued, with modifications, since 1947.
Although educational reforms have been introduced, institutional models have changed, and curricula have been revised several times, the colonial hangover continues. Alongside the influence of contemporary global powers and their dominant intellectual and economic models, we have not been able to completely decolonize ourselves because we frequently attempt to implement models of development borrowed from other societies. The model that we need should be indigenous, context-sensitive, and designed primarily for the benefit of our own people. Such a model has yet to be fully developed and implemented. We have conducted numerous experiments to improve the condition of the country in almost every field, political, social, economic, and financial, but so far, our success has remained partial. The construction of roads, motorways, buildings, and other physical infrastructure may be signs of development, but the real measure of progress lies in building, strengthening, and consolidating Pakistan's institutions in every sphere of national life. This institutional transformation is still waiting to take place.
At the time of decolonization, the rulers changed, and Pakistan experienced the same transformation. However, we did not fundamentally change the system or the principles and structures that also needed to be transformed. That is why, perhaps, we continue to function in ways that often reflect the requirements and mentality of the colonial system. For example, many of our rulers and government functionaries appear to regard authority as the ultimate objective. They need to realize that authority comes with responsibility. Instead, authority is sometimes exercised through excessive use of power, particularly to control citizens rather than to serve them. This is one of the reasons why an important process has remained weak in Pakistan: the development of an independent intellectual culture. Pakistan has a large number of universities and many highly qualified academics, including scholars with foreign qualifications. Yet academic qualifications alone do not necessarily produce independent intellectuals. Many academics continue to operate within institutional structures shaped by authority and control. They sometimes adopt the language, style, and tone of those in power rather than developing an independent intellectual voice.
In such a situation, meaningful public debate becomes difficult. And in the absence of open and critical debate, genuine progress, particularly intellectual progress, cannot take place. We achieved political independence from the colonial master, but we have not yet achieved complete intellectual independence. We continue to struggle to develop independent intellectuals, both within our universities and in wider society. As many intellectuals have argued, freedom and independence do not simply mean a change of rulers; they also mean the freedom and independence of the mind. Unless the minds of people are developed in such a way that they can think critically, question established assumptions, and work independently, genuine national progress cannot be achieved.
Therefore, the need of the hour is to transform our educational system, encourage meaningful social and intellectual debate, and cultivate a culture of intellectual independence. We need an environment in which critical thinking, questioning, disagreement, and constructive debate are not viewed as threats but as essential components of a healthy society. Only through such intellectual emancipation can we move towards an egalitarian society in which citizens enjoy their and equal rights and strong, accountable institutions serve the people rather than merely exercising authority over them because political independence gave us a country; intellectual independence can give us a truly decolonized nation.